VOYAGES (Emmanuel Finkiel, 1999)

In the first of the three linked episodes of French writer-director Emmanuel Finkiel’s delicate, poignant Voyages, a bus tour of Poland, by present-day French survivors of the Holocaust, suffers a mishap: en route to Auschwitz from a Jewish cemetery, the bus breaks down. Insofar as they once cheated the fate of the Six Million, the current everyday circumstance resonates with the earlier momentous circumstance, if ironically: elderly now, closer to the end than to the Holocaust, these individuals—tourists through life, like the rest of us—will never be able to unburden themselves of their guilty survival. Historically debt-ridden, they will go to their graves obligated to the Six Million. Some at least feel this way—for instance, Rivka, whose husband, who is accompanying her on the bus tour, however, cannot comprehend her upended emotions.
     Finkiel, who was an assistant director on the Three Colors trilogy (1993-1994), has adopted (in miniature) Krzysztof Kieślowski’s procedure there: each film—or, in Finkiel’s case, segment—with its own protagonist, its own story to tell, but with shared characters in a thematically driven whole. None of the stories are ever completed in a conventional sense; each story loses itself, in two cases yielding to the next. Even death, when it someday occurs, will complete nothing; stories—lives—will simply stop. From Warsaw, the film moves to Paris and then to Tel Aviv.
     In the second episode, Regine confronts the possibility that her father, long presumed to be among the Six Million, in fact survived; but is he her father? Incapable of being verified, is this refound connection ultimately an encapsulation of all Holocaust-generated lost familial connections? In the final episode, Russian-born Vera searches Israel for a cousin of hers, bemoaning the loss of Jewish identity: “There seems to be no more Jews in Israel—only Israelis.” Hardly anyone even speaks Yiddish anymore.
     From Poland, France and Belgium, Voyages won the prize of international critics at Vienna.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s