Irving Thalberg was Erich von Stroheim’s nemesis; he decimated Stroheim’s work first at one Hollywood studio and then at another. Thalberg, in my opinion, did not die young enough.
Fate, equipped with gleeful abandon, determines the merry-go-round of life. Disparate status and power, including victimization and sadistic cruelty; romance and also unrequited love: everything falls under Fate’s sway; everything is attached to its wild carousel. In such a universe, here set in pre-Great War Vienna, even an orangutan can emerge as an instrument of justice.
Like any true nemesis, Thalberg as much loved as hated the man he was driven to destroy; his was a textbook case of pathological jealousy. This production head fired Stroheim from Merry-Go-Round under the cloak of sparing Universal Stroheim’s meticulous care and prodigious costs. He substituted Rupert Julian, the future director of the tawdry Phantom of the Opera (1925), whose flat-footed contributions to Merry-Go-Round pale beside Stroheim’s dynamic, expressive work. The film proceeds from Stroheim’s own (and, to be honest, melodramatic) original story, but this isn’t credited; despite the fact that he directed whatever is of high value in the film, Stroheim isn’t credited as director, either. Thalberg kept the work and attributed it to someone else, thus brandishing his own ugly power and, without irony, extending the theme of the film.
It is facile, I suppose, to stress the innate “nobility” of a commoner (Mary Philbin, as innocent Agnes, has none of the complexity of Stroheim’s future Zasu Pitts), but I am especially moved and dazzled by Stroheim’s intricately active long-shots in palatial interiors, which beautifully contrast to the rough, brooding atmosphere permeating the carnival at night: life as a game, a hoax (like Jewish Stroheim’s own claims to European nobility); life as dangerous, deadly—a curse.
B(U)Y THE BOOK
MY BOOK, A Short Chronology of World Cinema, IS CURRENTLY AVAILABLE FROM THE SANDS FILMS CINEMA CLUB IN LONDON. USING EITHER OF THE LINKS BELOW, ACCESS THE ADVERTISEMENT FOR THIS BOOK, FROM WHICH YOU CAN ORDER ONE OR MORE COPIES OF IT. THANKS.